See #13570 for details --- the idea is that included the store dir in
store paths makes systematic JSON parting with e.g. Serde, Aeson,
nlohmann, or similiar harder.
After talking to Eelco, we are changing the `Derivation` format right
away because not only is `nix derivation` technically experimental, we think it is
also less widely used in practice than, say, `nix path-info`.
Progress on #13570
Instead of passing them around separately, or doing finicky logic in a
try-catch block to recover them, just make `BuildError` always contain a
status, and make it the thrower's responsibility to set it. This is much
more simple and explicit.
Once that change is done, split the `done` functions of `DerivationGoal`
and `DerivationBuildingGoal` into separate success and failure
functions, which ends up being easier to understand and hardly any
duplication.
Also, change the handling of failures in resolved cases to use
`BuildResult::DependencyFailed` and a new message. This is because the
underlying derivation will also get its message printed --- which is
good, because in general the resolved derivation is not unique. One dyn
drv test had to be updated, but CA (and dyn drv) is experimental, so I
do not mind.
Finally, delete `SubstError` because it is unused.
This method does *not* create a new type of goal. We instead just make
`DerivationGoal` more sophisticated, which is much easier to do now that
`DerivationBuildingGoal` has been split from it (and so many fields are
gone, or or local variables instead).
This avoids the need for a secondarily trampoline goal that interacted
poorly with `addWantedOutputs`. That, I hope, will mean the bugs from
before do not reappear.
There may in fact be a reason to introduce such a trampoline in the
future, but it would only happen in conjunction with getting rid of
`addWantedOutputs`.
Restores the functionality (and tests) that was reverted in
f4f28cdd0e.
The bug reappeared after all, and the fix introduced a different bug. I
just reverted on 2.27 first, in #12576, but upon further introspection
and discussion with @roberth, with preparing for and travelling to
Planet Nix I will not be able to fix it on `master` soon enough for a
revert to not be warranted here in the meantime also.
This reverts commit c98525235f.
"content-address*ed*" derivation is misleading because all derivations
are *themselves* content-addressed. What may or may not be
content-addressed is not derivation itself, but the *output* of the
derivation.
The outputs are not *part* of the derivation (for then the derivation
wouldn't be complete before we built it) but rather separate entities
produced by the derivation.
"content-adddress*ed*" is not correctly because it can only describe
what the derivation *is*, and that is not what we are trying to do.
"content-address*ing*" is correct because it describes what the
derivation *does* --- it produces content-addressed data.
This fixes dynamic derivations, reverting #9081.
I believe that this time around, #9052 is fixed. When I first rebased
this, tests were failing (which wasn't the case before). The cause of
those test failures were due to the crude job in which the outer goal
tried to exit with the inner goal's status.
Now, that error handling has been reworked to be more faithful. The exit
exit status and exception of the inner goal is returned by the outer
goal. The exception was what was causing the test failures, but I
believe it was not having the right error code (there is more than one
for failure) that caused #9081.
The only cost of doing things the "right way" was that I had to
introduce a hacky `preserveException` boolean. I don't like this, but,
then again, none of us like anything about how the scheduler works.
Issue #11927 is still there to clean everything up, subsuming the need
for any `preserveException` because I doubt we will be fishing
information out of state machines like this at all.
This reverts commit 8440afbed7.
Co-Authored-By: Eelco Dolstra <edolstra@gmail.com>
I think it is bad for these reasons when `tests/` contains a mix of
functional and integration tests
- Concepts is harder to understand, the documentation makes a good
unit vs functional vs integration distinction, but when the
integration tests are just two subdirs within `tests/` this is not
clear.
- Source filtering in the `flake.nix` is more complex. We need to
filter out some of the dirs from `tests/`, rather than simply pick
the dirs we want and take all of them. This is a good sign the
structure of what we are trying to do is not matching the structure
of the files.
With this change we have a clean:
```shell-session
$ git show 'HEAD:tests'
tree HEAD:tests
functional/
installer/
nixos/
```
